Why some passive ETFs make bigger bets than active funds

Rules-based ETFs can use specialized indexes to concentrate holdings and add exposure beyond dominant technology stocks, analysts say.

Some passive exchange-traded funds can make larger portfolio bets than funds labeled active because their indexes use detailed rules to select companies, set weightings and rebalance holdings. The structure of a strategy can tell investors more about an ETF’s exposure than its active or passive label.

The distinction matters for investors seeking artificial intelligence exposure without adding more holdings in Nvidia, Microsoft, Apple and other large technology companies. A portfolio that combines global, S&P 500, technology, AI and semiconductor ETFs can remain concentrated in those companies, even when it contains several funds.

An analysis of hypothetical ETF combinations found that adding the Global X Robotics & Artificial Intelligence ETF, known as BOTZ, increased exposure to companies outside the largest U.S. technology names. Nvidia was the only company from that group among BOTZ’s top 10 holdings in the analysis. The fund also held companies such as Fanuc, Keyence and ABB.

The U.S. version of BOTZ tracks an Indxx thematic index. Its European UCITS version tracks a related Indxx v2 index. Indxx sets rules for which companies qualify, how much they weigh in the index and when the holdings are reviewed and changed.

Those decisions are made before an ETF begins tracking the index. The fund can therefore take a concentrated position while remaining classified as passive because it follows predetermined rules rather than a portfolio manager’s discretionary trades.

Kenneth Lamont, a principal at Morningstar, described active and passive investing as a continuum. Broad market-cap-weighted index funds that seek to mirror the market are at one end. High-conviction stock-picking funds that make large discretionary bets are at the other. The middle includes thematic, factor, quantitative and systematic strategies.

“The investment decisions are still active in nature, they have simply been codified into an index methodology,” Lamont said. He added that the active or passive label often describes how a strategy is delivered rather than the amount of investment judgment behind it.

“Passive describes how a strategy is implemented, not how it was designed,” said Pedro Palandrani, Global X’s head of product research and development. He described BOTZ as covering the “physical layer of automation,” including sensors, servo motors, machine-vision systems and industrial robots, with exposure to companies in Japan and Europe.

Index providers are developing methods that use revenue screens and natural-language processing. These systems can identify a company’s exposure to a theme in financial filings before that exposure appears in standard sector classifications.

Rules-based ETFs may respond more slowly to new events than funds managed by active investment teams. Their methodologies can produce holdings, weightings and changes that differ from broad market trackers and active funds invested in popular technology stocks. Investors can assess those features by reviewing an ETF’s holdings, weighting rules and rebalancing schedule.

Articles by this author