UK watchdog flags surveillance failures at MI5, GCHQ

The UK’s investigatory powers watchdog found agencies breached surveillance safeguards, including MI5, which gave false evidence to courts about a violent neo-Nazi informer.

The UK’s Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office (IPCO) found that several government agencies failed to follow legal safeguards for surveillance and covert powers in its 2025 annual report.

Sir Brian Leveson, the Investigatory Powers Commissioner, described the failures as “disappointed and concerned” and said MI5 had given false evidence to the High Court and the Investigatory Powers Tribunal about its handling of Agent X, a violent neo-Nazi informer. He called the case “as serious as anything I have dealt with as Commissioner.”

The findings raised questions about whether parts of the framework, including rules under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, remained clear and fit for purpose. “None of these are minor administrative failures,” Leveson said. “Operational pressures are real, but they do not reduce the need for lawful, consistent and well-understood safeguards.”

GCHQ was criticised for failing to account for thousands of missing removable storage devices that may contain classified information. The devices included USB sticks, external hard drives and memory cards. IPCO had asked GCHQ to investigate the missing items several years ago. In 2025, GCHQ introduced a tool to monitor the issue, storage and location of removable media.

His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service continued to make recurring errors when intercepting prisoners’ communications. In one case, calls between a prisoner and a solicitor were intercepted after the phone number was wrongly identified as belonging to a social contact. The calls were not listened to, but the error created a risk of significant prejudice or harm.

The National Crime Agency’s handling of covert human intelligence sources and undercover operations fell “well short” of legal requirements. Inspectors found weaknesses in oversight and record-keeping. Large volumes of records remained beyond their scheduled review dates, and some records could not be reliably linked to specific investigations or people. The findings raised questions about whether the records could lawfully be retained.

The Police Service of Northern Ireland failed to disclose surveillance operations involving Belfast journalists Barry McCaffrey and Trevor Birney during an IPCO inspection. It also failed to disclose covert monitoring of investigative journalist Dónal MacIntyre’s social media activity. An interim inspection in December 2025 found no evidence that the PSNI’s anti-corruption unit used a separate system to bypass authorisation requirements for accessing journalists’ phone records.

The Ministry of Defence failed to apply safeguards properly when people detained overseas were interrogated or interviewed to gather intelligence for the UK. GCHQ also wrongly identified people as terrorism suspects after a problem with an undisclosed software application. Five people were stopped and searched under Schedule 7 of the Terrorism Act 2000, detained, and had their devices downloaded and biometric details taken.

Applications for communications data, such as records showing who contacted whom and when, rose by almost 9% in 2025 to about 28,000. The report recorded more errors, including four classified as serious. In one case, inaccurate data led to a person’s arrest and release on bail during an investigation into the sharing of indecent images of children. In another, police searched the wrong home.

Data from one mobile operator produced 72 false positives and 88 false negatives when internet protocol addresses were identified. Two innocent people were arrested. A telecommunications timing error led police to arrest the wrong person during an investigation into a caller who had threatened serious harm. In an earlier case, an innocent person was detained for questioning, while three generations of the same family were questioned at separate addresses.

Leveson said IPCO’s independent oversight remained effective. “I remain satisfied that, across a demanding and fast-changing environment, the system of checks on the use of covert powers continues to operate with rigour and independence,” he said. IPCO oversees investigatory powers used by intelligence agencies, police forces and other public authorities across about 600 bodies.

Articles by this author