Third Capture conviction referred to Court of Appeal

The CCRC has referred former subpostmaster Narinder Aujla’s 1998 theft conviction to the Court of Appeal after losses appeared in his Capture-based accounts.

The Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred former Dudley subpostmaster Narinder Aujla’s 1998 theft conviction to the Court of Appeal. It is the third conviction linked to the Post Office’s Capture accounting system to be referred for appeal.

Aujla, now 61, was convicted at Wolverhampton Crown Court after a £10,000 shortfall appeared in his Capture-based accounts. He was sentenced to four months in prison and had to repay the money after his release.

Capture was installed in Post Office branches during the 1990s to replace paper-based accounting, before the introduction of Horizon. Aujla said he began finding unexplained discrepancies after Capture was installed and used his own money to cover the shortfalls.

When he could no longer do so, a Post Office helpline adviser told him to “roll the losses over” to the following week, according to his account. Each time he followed the advice, the reported shortfall increased.

The CCRC said new evidence, considered with independent findings about Capture, created a real possibility that the Court of Appeal would find Aujla’s prosecution was an abuse of process.

CCRC chair Vera Baird KC said in a statement that several pre-Horizon cases appeared to involve false losses later attributed to Post Office staff. She described Aujla’s referral as the third Capture-related conviction sent to the Court of Appeal and said it added to evidence that Capture had generated incorrect losses.

Baird added that convictions in these cases had affected people’s livelihoods, finances, reputations and family lives.

The CCRC referred former Bury subpostmaster Steve Marston’s conviction for appeal in March 2026. It also referred the 1998 conviction of Patricia Owen, who died in 2003. The appeals in those cases are due to be heard by the Court of Appeal in January 2027.

Aujla’s case is the fourth involving a pre-Horizon Post Office system to reach the appeal process. The other case concerns a prosecution involving APT/APS, another accounting system used in Post Office branches.

The CCRC is reviewing 12 prosecutions linked to Capture. Unlike Horizon-related convictions, which were overturned in large numbers through legislation, Capture-related convictions are being considered individually by the CCRC and the courts.

Evidence about unexplained losses under Capture was highlighted in January 2024. In December 2024, the government promised financial redress and legal remedies for people affected by Capture problems.

Forensic experts at Kroll later found a “reasonable likelihood” that Capture had caused accounting losses. The government has announced an investigation into other pre-Horizon systems, including APT/APS, ECCO+, ALPS and ESNS. Capture is excluded because separate work has already established problems with the system.

Articles by this author