Tesla Stock Falls 3% as SpaceX Merger Benefits Questioned
Tesla shares fell more than 3% Friday after HSBC questioned the near-term benefits and dilution risks of a possible merger with SpaceX.
Tesla shares fell more than 3% on Friday after analysts questioned the potential benefits of a reported merger with SpaceX. The transaction has not been confirmed, and its terms are unknown.
HSBC upgraded Tesla to Hold from Reduce and raised its price target to $359 from $157. The new target still implies about 4% downside from Tesla’s previous closing price.
HSBC analyst Michael Tyndall said the strategic rationale for combining the companies was unclear because Tesla and SpaceX operate in different markets and have limited short-term business links. The bank identified control as a possible reason for considering the transaction.
Elon Musk owns about 39% of SpaceX and controls roughly 70% of its voting rights. His ownership and voting control at Tesla are about 20%. Tyndall said SpaceX could become the surviving company in a merger, allowing Musk to retain majority voting control of the combined business.
HSBC estimated that a 33% premium could value Tesla at $507 per share. The bank gave equal weight to that estimate and its fundamental valuation, producing the $359 price target.
A merger could give SpaceX access to Tesla’s equity and reduce the need for future fundraising. SpaceX faces large investment needs related to artificial intelligence and data centers, which HSBC said exceed Tesla’s capital requirements. HSBC maintained a Hold rating on SpaceX and a $150 price target.
Tesla investor Gary Black, who runs The Future Fund LLC, warned of risks from a stock-for-stock transaction. In a post on X, he cited the proposed combination of Lumentum Holdings and Marvell Technology. Marvell shares fell 45% in just over a month after the deal was announced, reducing the value of the premium offered to Lumentum shareholders, according to Black.
Black said Tesla shareholders could initially benefit from a rise in Tesla shares after a merger announcement, followed by selling pressure as investors sought to realize gains in SpaceX shares. Using a Tesla share price of $374, he estimated that a potential 24% premium paid in SpaceX stock could imply a value of $464 per Tesla share. He estimated that value could fall to about $280 within a month if SpaceX faced dilution of as much as 50%.
Black’s dilution scenario is an assessment of potential risks and does not reflect confirmed transaction terms. HSBC also identified regulatory risks, including Tesla’s manufacturing operations and revenue exposure in China.








