Small RIAs Face a Choice on Data Ownership and Costs

At an ADVISE AI conference in Austin, Michael Kitces and Joel Bruckenstein urged smaller RIAs to check data quality, ownership terms and exit fees before building their own systems.

Michael Kitces and Joel Bruckenstein debated data ownership and technology costs at the ADVISE AI conference in Austin, Texas. Suzanne Siracuse moderated the discussion, which examined whether artificial intelligence will increase or reduce the value of financial advice.

The conversation focused on how much control registered investment advisers need over their data and when they should rely on outside technology providers. Siracuse noted that calls to “own your data” have often focused on larger firms and asked how smaller firms should respond.

Kitces, chief financial planning nerd at Kitces.com, questioned whether most smaller firms need large data warehouses. Larger firms have spent millions of dollars building data systems and business intelligence dashboards, often without a specific use for the information, he said.

The arrival of AI led some firms to consolidate more data for AI applications. Kitces said firms sometimes built systems that outside providers could have supplied at a lower cost. Paying licensing fees for customer relationship management and other software could have cost less than creating large internal systems, he added.

Firm-owned technology can still support specific workflows, including note-taking and customer relationship management. Kitces also linked proprietary systems to adviser retention, saying they can connect advisers more closely to a firm.

Bruckenstein, president of Technology Tools for Today, described a firm that built a custom AI system after improving the quality of its data. The system was efficient and cost-effective, he said, but the approach currently suits about the top 1% or 2% of firms in the industry.

Kitces expects many firms to receive AI capabilities from outside providers rather than through large internal data projects. Bruckenstein agreed that smaller firms should first clean their data, including before moving from one portfolio management system to another.

He also urged firms to review contracts with portfolio management software providers. Agreements may not clearly identify who owns the data or how the firm can transfer it, he said. Even when a firm owns its data, retrieving it can result in an exit fee of tens of thousands of dollars.

Outsourcing data warehousing can work for a small firm if it understands the provider’s terms, according to Bruckenstein. Before signing an agreement, advisers should ask, “What’s my exit strategy?”

Articles by this author