Before recommending a Section 351 ETF, check the IRS warning

The IRS and Treasury said a specific Section 351 ETF exchange pattern may be taxable when funds quickly swap securities they do not plan to hold.

The IRS and Treasury Department issued guidance in late September warning that a specific Section 351 ETF exchange pattern may be taxable. The guidance was released with Notice 2026-62, which seeks public comment on the transactions and other tax strategies.

The pattern involves a fund accepting securities it does not intend to keep, exchanging those holdings with an authorized participant shortly after the fund launches and ending up with a materially different portfolio. The IRS may treat the arrangement as a direct trade between the investor and the authorized participant, rather than as a tax-deferred contribution to the ETF.

Investors involved in such an exchange could owe capital-gains tax on the securities that were swapped out, along with interest. The guidance does not classify the transactions as fraud and does not impose penalties or reporting requirements on fund sponsors or advisers at this time. Future guidance could add reporting requirements or penalties.

Section 351 generally allows an investor to contribute securities to a newly created ETF in exchange for ETF shares without recognizing a gain immediately. The investor’s cost basis and holding period carry over to the ETF shares, deferring the gain until the shares are sold.

The contributed portfolio must meet diversification requirements. No single issuer may account for more than 25% of the portfolio, and the five largest issuers together may not account for more than 50%. The securities must also match the ETF’s investment strategy.

The IRS guidance focuses on transactions in which a fund accepts securities it does not plan to retain and soon exchanges them with an authorized participant for securities the fund wants to hold. Tax lawyers have previously advised Section 351 ETF sponsors to accept only securities they intend to keep.

Before recommending a Section 351 ETF, advisers should check whether the client’s holdings fit the fund’s strategy, whether the portfolio meets the 25% and 50% diversification limits, whether the fund will accept all contributed securities and whether it plans to retain them. The tax treatment may depend on how the fund operates after receiving the securities.

The IRS has not prohibited Section 351 exchanges. ExchangiFi, a tax technology company, counted 123 live Section 351 ETFs launched since 2019, with more than $25 billion in seed capital. ETF holdings can provide diversification, liquidity and transparency, and may carry lower fees. ETF shares are held in brokerage accounts and can generally be margined.

Articles by this author