RIA Leaders 2026: Custody fee debate puts costs in focus

U.S. fee-only advisers and custodians are debating explicit custody fees as firms struggle to compare what clients pay through cash management, lending and product payments.

The debate over explicit custody fees is intensifying among U.S. fee-only registered investment advisers and the custodians that hold their clients’ assets. The fee-only planning channel has nearly $4 trillion in assets under management, yet advisers often cannot calculate the total cost of custody services.

Custodians including Charles Schwab, Fidelity Investments and BNY Pershing negotiate pricing privately with advisory firms. Some publicly list recurring fees, while others set prices based on the adviser and services provided. Costs may be paid by the advisory firm, passed to clients or included in other charges.

Custodians also earn revenue from interest on client cash, securities lending, margin lending, payments from fund companies and other investment-product arrangements. Advisers generally have limited information about the combined cost of those revenue sources for their clients.

That lack of consistent pricing has raised questions for advisers with a fiduciary duty to put clients’ interests first. “There really isn’t any way to qualify what you’re going to get for what you’re paying,” wrote Bob Veres, founder of Inside Information and an industry commentator.

Natalie Pine, CEO of Briaud Financial Advisors in College Station, Texas, described how her firm moved about $500 million from Fidelity to Schwab in 2020 after facing the possibility of an annual custody charge. The potential cost was about $200,000 for the firm, or $250 per account or 0.05% of assets if passed to clients.

Pine described Fidelity as a strong provider for the firm’s first 20 years, but the potential charge was too high for the practice. Schwab has pledged never to charge a custody fee. The transition required Briaud to take additional steps to help clients avoid Schwab’s cash-sweep programs, which can reduce returns on liquid portfolio holdings.

“Custodians have to get paid,” Pine said. “My view is, there’s not a right or a wrong. You have to pick what’s best for your clients and your firm if you’re an advisor.”

Financial planning researchers Michael Kitces and Adam Van Deusen have proposed replacing much of the current system with an asset-based custody fee. Under their model, custodians would charge a stated percentage of assets held on their platforms and return revenue collected above an agreed ceiling. Their examples included annual caps of 0.05% to 0.25%.

Kitces and Van Deusen wrote that the model could connect custodians’ revenue to assets on their platforms rather than less visible income sources. Kitces’ calculations using Schwab’s public disclosures found that the company’s revenue per asset fell to 0.092% in 2024 from 0.155% in 2022.

The proposed system could increase costs for some accounts, including portfolios holding individual stocks. Rebates could require new technology and accounting systems. A direct fee could also encourage advisory firms to combine operations to obtain lower pricing through scale.

Schwab and Fidelity have shown little interest in replacing their current models with an industry-wide custody-fee system. Schwab described custody as a capital-intensive, regulated business and said revenue of about 0.10% leaves limited room for error. “Scale is what makes this sustainable,” former Schwab CEO and current co-chairman Walt Bettinger wrote in a public post.

Fidelity described custody fees as one possible payment method in relationships among advisers, custodians and clients. The company declined to discuss the policy change that led Briaud to leave its platform.

The Securities and Exchange Commission has warned advisers to disclose and address conflicts tied to third-party payments, cash-management programs and product compensation. Its examination priorities include whether firms’ policies prevent them from putting their interests ahead of clients’ interests and whether disclosures explain fee-related conflicts.

Daniel Yerger, president and chief compliance officer of MY Wealth Planners in Longmont, Colorado, urged advisers to request more information from custodians and review their platforms regularly. He also warned that a custody fee would not guarantee the end of other revenue sources. “What I’d almost rather see is just net expense disclosure in statements,” Yerger said.

The fee-only market includes more than 5,500 firms serving mainly individual wealth-management clients without charging commissions. The firms account for about 16.6 million clients, 43,000 employees and 18,000 advisers across nearly 6,000 U.S. offices, according to industry data.

Articles by this author