How to distinguish responsible credit from predatory lending

A former Illinois regulator who helped draft the state’s 36% loan cap outlines how to assess credit products, including rent-payment services.

A former Illinois financial regulator who helped draft the state’s 36% cap on consumer-loan interest rates has outlined criteria for distinguishing responsible credit products from predatory lending.

The former regulator, who previously worked as a consumer advocate, helped develop the Payday Loan Reform Act, the Illinois Community Reinvestment Act and the Predatory Loan Prevention Act. The regulator later led the agency that enforced the rate cap.

Rent-payment products merit closer review because rent is often due on a fixed date while income arrives on a different schedule. Inflation-adjusted median rent rose 30% from 2001 to 2024, while median renter household income increased 9%, according to the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University.

The gap has contributed to the growth of products that let customers divide rent into several payments, schedule payments around their paychecks or borrow briefly against expected income. These products can help customers avoid late fees, overdraft charges or missed payments. Some, however, use structures associated with payday loans.

The regulator’s criteria include whether a product costs less than the alternatives, whether its cost rises when repayment takes longer and whether fees or interest compound. Other questions include whether the company earns more when a customer falls behind, whether the full cost is disclosed before the customer agrees and whether the customer can leave the product without facing greater financial pressure.

Payday loans generally fail those tests. They can carry annualized costs of 300% to 500%. Some pay-later products have fixed terms, limited or no late fees and a cap on the total cost, according to the regulator.

Missed-payment policies offer another way to compare products. Customers can check whether a late payment triggers an additional fee, whether the balance remains fixed and whether missed payments are reported to credit bureaus. Some products report on-time payments, if at all, without reporting missed payments.

The regulator also called for evidence on customers’ longer-term outcomes. Regulators reviewing bank charter applications, lawmakers and state attorneys general can ask whether customers use a product for a specific short-term need and then stop, or whether repeated use becomes routine. They can also examine whether use improves, worsens or leaves unchanged a customer’s financial position.

Companies that provide evidence of responsible outcomes should be assessed differently from those that cannot document how their products affect borrowers, the regulator said. That distinction would not exempt any company from future scrutiny.

The regulator urged oversight bodies to focus on specific practices rather than condemn every product in a category. Companies that follow standards such as the Consumer Reports Fairness by Design Playbook can be assessed against conduct that exceeds minimum legal requirements.

Responsible credit products would remain subject to enforcement, legislation and consumer education, according to the regulator. Regulators could also issue guidance on product features that reduce the risk of borrowers becoming trapped in debt.

Articles by this author