Private Credit Investors Face Unexpected Tax Bills

Private credit investors may receive late K-1 forms, file tax returns in several states and owe taxes on income they have not received in cash.

Private credit investors face tax obligations that can include late Schedule K-1 forms, multistate filings and taxes on undistributed income. The added work has led some investors to reconsider private credit vehicles and other alternative investments.

Investors in private credit funds structured as partnerships generally receive Schedule K-1 forms reporting their share of income, deductions and other tax items. The forms often arrive in August or September, after the usual April filing deadline, so investors may need to request extensions.

“With the rise of alternative investments, it’s created a lot of tax complexity,” said Samuel Diarbakerly, founder and CEO of Boston-based wealth management firm Generation Capital Advisors.

Investors who hold large positions in vehicles that operate across state lines may have to file tax returns in each state where the investment conducts business. David Askew, managing partner overseeing Mercer Advisors’ Southern California advisory teams, said some clients have had to file returns in three or four states because of a fund’s domicile.

“If someone is trying to do their own taxes, they may not recognize that they’re going to have to do multistate filings,” Askew said. Multiple K-1 forms can also increase tax-preparation fees, he added.

Filing extensions can create a risk of tax-related identity fraud. Askew advised clients to take precautions against fraudsters who file returns in their names and claim refunds before the legitimate returns are submitted. Taxpayers can obtain electronic-filing passwords and arrange them with their tax preparers, he said.

Investors may also owe tax on “phantom income,” or income reported for tax purposes but not distributed in cash. Askew recommended reviewing tax projections during the year and keeping additional cash available for potential payments.

Private credit funds and other alternative investments may restrict withdrawals, making it harder for investors to raise cash for tax bills. Diarbakerly described one client who inherited a hedge fund that allowed withdrawals once a year and limited them to 10% of the investment.

“That makes paying our taxes impossible, and we can’t even get out of this thing,” the client told the firm, according to Diarbakerly.

“I think the alts mania is going to start playing out that people don’t want them anymore. The clients have no idea how these things work,” Diarbakerly said.

Generation Capital Advisors continues to use alternative investments in some cases, including retirement accounts, family foundations and charitable lead annuity trusts. Those account types and entities may reduce or avoid some of the filing requirements.

Private credit continues to attract investors, Askew said. Some clients have told him they wanted to understand the tax effects before investing in certain vehicles.

Articles by this author