Large fee-only RIAs lose share to hybrid, insurance rivals

Fee-only RIAs with at least $5 billion in assets lost 8 percentage points of market share in five years as hybrid and insurance-licensed firms grew faster, Cerulli found.

Fee-only registered investment advisers with at least $5 billion in client assets lost market share to similarly sized hybrid and insurance-licensed firms over the past five years, according to research from Cerulli Associates commissioned by Credent Wealth Management.

The number of RIAs with at least $5 billion in client assets rose 77% during the period to 343 firms. Fee-only firms grew at an 8% compound annual rate to 121 firms. Hybrid RIAs, which operate a brokerage business, grew at a 12% rate to 186 firms. Independent RIAs with insurance licenses grew at a 37% rate to 36 firms.

Fee-only firms’ share of assets fell by 8 percentage points to 34%. Hybrid firms held a 51% share, unchanged over the period. Insurance-licensed firms doubled their share to 14%, Cerulli found.

Large advisory firms have expanded through mergers and acquisitions and added brokerage or insurance capabilities. Executives at those firms have cited broader services and lower costs. Critics say product sales, commissions and revenue-sharing arrangements can create conflicts that fee-only firms avoid.

Credent, based in Auburn, Indiana, reached $5 billion in assets after receiving an 11% minority investment in 2025 and additional financing in 2024 from Crestline Investors, an alternative investment manager and private-credit firm. Co-founder and CEO David Hefty told prospective investors that Credent would remain a fee-only fiduciary firm.

“If you don’t like that, don’t give us a bid,” Hefty recalled. About 15 firms withdrew from the bidding process, he said.

Credent commissioned the study because some fee-only RIAs have begun to resemble broker-dealers, Hefty said. “It’s more important that we do what we believe is right,” he said. “And we can grow and scale and compete in a way that does not charge excessive costs to our investors.”

Using RIA disclosures to the Securities and Exchange Commission, Cerulli calculated that clients with $1.5 million in assets pay an average of 1.47% annually in advisory and investment product fees. Advisory fees account for 0.92 percentage points, while investment products account for 0.55 percentage points.

Product costs varied by portfolio type. Investors with portfolios heavily weighted toward exchange-traded funds paid an average product fee of 0.34%, compared with 0.56% for heavy mutual-fund users and 0.78% for heavy alternative-investment users.

Cerulli’s Affluent Investor Tracker found that half of respondents described themselves as advised investors in 2025, up from 35% in 2009. At least 69% said they were willing to pay for advice, compared with 35% in 2009.

About one-third of affluent investors reported paying asset-based fees, 22% paid commissions and 10% paid a retainer or another flat fee. Fifteen percent did not know how their adviser or wealth management firm was paid.

Among investors whose providers were required to act in their best interests, 73% were satisfied and not seeking a new provider. That compared with 48% of investors whose providers could recommend products that put the provider’s interests ahead of the client’s.

“We are wildly passionate about educating investors that they have a choice,” Hefty said. “Fee-only advice is still out there today. There are thousands of advisors offering it, and they just need to do a quick search and find one.”

Stephen Caruso, Cerulli’s director of wealth management, attributed the growth of brokerage and insurance capabilities to firms’ efforts to offer a broader range of services. Natalie Pine, immediate past chair of the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors and CEO of Briaud Financial Advisors, called for clearer disclosure of how advisers and their companies are paid.

“Being fee-only is a choice — any advisor can choose it on any given day,” Hefty said.

Articles by this author