IRS Rollover Guidance May Leave Advisors Wanting More
Proposed IRS and Treasury procedures could standardize rollovers, but they would leave paper checks and manual paperwork in place.
The IRS and Treasury Department are preparing final guidance on rollovers from employer retirement plans to individual retirement accounts. The agencies issued a notice with sample forms and optional procedures in August and accepted public comments through Oct. 23.
The proposal would standardize parts of the rollover process but would not require plan sponsors, custodians or recordkeepers to use fully digital systems. Advisors and financial institutions urged the agencies to reduce paperwork and replace paper checks with electronic transfers.
Rollovers from plans such as 401(k)s can help clients consolidate retirement accounts and may reduce fees. Advisors and custodians said delays in the current process can discourage clients from completing rollovers.
George Poole, a New York City-based advisor, described a transaction that required wet signatures and repeated mailings between the distributing and receiving custodians. The receiving custodian had to sign an acceptance form and return it by mail before the transaction could proceed, Poole wrote in a comment letter.
Poole recommended that the final procedures explain authentication requirements for each party and require providers to keep clients informed throughout the process.
Iurii Nosenko, an advisor in Weston, Florida, urged the agencies to remove paper checks from the process. He recommended phasing in the change based on plan size, followed by a deadline after which direct rollovers would use electronic funds transfers, including automated clearinghouse payments or wires.
Fidelity Investments also criticized the continued use of paper checks. In a comment letter, General Counsel Roberto Braceras wrote that different data requirements, manual documents and paper checks create longer processing times, operational risks and confusion for participants.
Fidelity asked Treasury not to require specific authentication technologies or fraud-prevention tools. Braceras wrote that financial institutions need flexibility because fraud risks and available technologies change over time.
Betterment recommended standardizing digital transfers and prohibiting procedures it considers burdensome, including distribution letters and medallion signature guarantees. Joshua Rubin, the company’s vice president of legal, and Caroline Wallace, its legal counsel, wrote that paper communications can cause delays and errors and allow providers to add requirements that discourage rollovers.
The proposal also raises questions about how custodians and recordkeepers will determine whether a participant is eligible for a distribution and how much of an account is vested. Denise Appleby, CEO of Appleby Retirement Consulting in Grayson, Georgia, recommended that employers’ plan administrators certify those details before a rollover is processed.
The IRS and Treasury are expected to review the comments before issuing final guidance. Until then, the proposed procedures remain optional.








