Investors Look Beyond U.S. Megacaps to Small-Cap Stocks

Brent Leadbetter of TMX VettaFi urged investors to consider U.S. small-cap and international stocks at a webcast, citing high U.S. large-cap valuations and market concentration.

Investors should consider U.S. small-cap and international stocks as alternatives to concentrated portfolios of U.S. megacap companies, Brent Leadbetter of TMX VettaFi said at a recent webcast. He cited elevated valuations for U.S. large-cap stocks and lower valuations in several overseas markets.

Leadbetter, head of RAFI Distribution at TMX VettaFi, said the U.S. large-cap market had a Shiller cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio, or CAPE, of about 40 at the time of the webcast. That translated into an earnings yield of roughly 2.5%.

The CAPE ratio compares stock prices with average inflation-adjusted earnings over 10 years. Leadbetter said investors should use current valuations when estimating future returns instead of relying only on long-term historical averages. Under the Grinold-Kroner framework, equity returns come from income yield, earnings growth and changes in valuation.

He compared the market’s concentration in artificial intelligence-related megacap stocks with the technology boom of the late 1990s. Investors relying on the previous decade’s performance would have favored growth stocks in 1999, when diversification had lagged. On a forward-looking basis, reducing exposure to expensive growth stocks before the market downturn that began in 2000 would have produced a different result, he told attendees.

Leadbetter did not recommend eliminating U.S. large-cap growth stocks. He described rebalancing as a way to reduce exposure to highly valued holdings and add asset classes that had lagged. He compared diversification with insurance, saying investors should obtain it before a market decline or shift in leadership.

U.S. small-cap stocks can reduce exposure to the Magnificent Seven, a group of large technology and technology-related companies that accounts for a substantial share of the U.S. market’s total value. Small-cap stocks had lower valuations than the largest U.S. companies at the time of the webcast, according to Leadbetter.

He also discussed fundamental-weighted strategies, which select and weight companies using financial measures rather than market capitalization. These strategies can reduce exposure to companies whose prices have risen sharply and to unprofitable companies in some small-cap indexes. The Invesco RAFI US 1500 Small-Mid ETF, which trades under the ticker PRFZ, was cited as an example.

International stocks had a separate valuation gap. Developed markets outside the U.S. traded at CAPE ratios in the low 20s, about half the U.S. level, while emerging markets averaged close to 20, according to Leadbetter. Brazil and China traded at single-digit or low-teen multiples.

Leadbetter noted that market-capitalization-weighted international indexes can still be concentrated. Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix together accounted for about 30% of the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, while Taiwan’s CAPE ratio was near 50, he said. The Schwab Fundamental International Equity ETF, or FNDF, was cited as an example of a fundamentally weighted international fund.

The webcast focused on the risk of allocating to market segments after their valuations have risen. Leadbetter described disciplined rebalancing as a way to spread exposure across U.S. small-caps, developed markets outside the U.S. and emerging markets.

Articles by this author