How Social Security Framing Shapes Clients’ Claiming Plans

A survey of 1,603 people younger than 60 found that the Social Security ages clients knew influenced when they planned to claim benefits.

A survey experiment involving 1,603 people younger than 60 found that the Social Security claiming ages people knew influenced their intended claiming dates. The researchers said advisors should first identify clients’ existing assumptions before discussing when to claim benefits.

Eric Ludwig and Loren Flood of the American College of Financial Services found that respondents’ plans varied according to which age limits they knew. People who knew only that benefits could begin at age 62 planned to claim about 0.86 years earlier. Those who knew only that they could delay benefits until age 70 planned to claim about 0.62 years later.

The study found that 64.1% of respondents knew neither age 62 nor age 70. Only 12.7% knew both. Awareness of age 62 was more common than awareness of age 70: 14.5% knew the earliest claiming age, compared with 8.7% who knew the latest.

The findings were published Oct. 1, as Congress considers changes to the Social Security Administration’s terminology. H.R. 5284, the Claiming Age Clarity Act, passed the House in December 2025 and the Senate on Sept. 29. The bill is awaiting President Donald Trump’s signature.

If enacted, the law would replace “early eligibility age” with “minimum monthly benefit age.” It would rename “full retirement age” and “normal retirement age,” which range from 65 to 67 depending on a person’s birth year, as “standard monthly benefit age.” The administration would also use “maximum monthly benefit age” for age 70 instead of referring to delayed retirement credits.

Ludwig and Flood found that changing the labels alone did not alter respondents’ choices. They recommended that advisors find out what clients already believe about Social Security and explain how each claiming option would affect income.

“ A problem that advisors face is that the client already comes in with a preconceived idea that they’re going to claim at age whatever-that-is,” Ludwig wrote. Advisors may need to explain why a preferred claiming age could be too early and discuss other options.

The researchers also found that many people may confuse their retirement age with the age at which they claim Social Security. Ludwig described these existing assumptions as “anchors” that advisors should identify before making a recommendation.

Flood wrote that concerns about the Social Security trust fund should be addressed with information about what a projected shortfall could mean for benefits. The researchers also recommended showing dollar amounts instead of relying only on percentages or age comparisons.

The study examined the break-even age, when the higher payments from delaying benefits equal the payments a person would have received by claiming earlier. That point often falls between ages 78 and 81. Break-even explanations did not lead respondents to plan later claims, while explanations based on claiming ages did, Ludwig wrote. He and Flood found that break-even framing could make Social Security appear to be an investment choice rather than income intended to last throughout retirement.

Samuel Diarbakerly, founder and CEO of Generation Capital Advisors in Boston, reported that clients more often misunderstand how Social Security works than know only one end of the claiming range. He noted that life span and future tax rates are unknown, so his firm treats claiming as a decision about protecting lifetime income rather than a bet on a specific break-even age.

Robert J. Patterson, CEO of San Diego-based RJ Patterson Group, noted that claiming choices also depend on a client’s age, financial situation and cash-flow needs. He said the way advisors present the information can affect how clients respond to the available options.

Articles by this author