Hedge Funds Expand Role In Private Equity Deal Suits

Hedge funds have brought or sought to lead at least 11 Delaware cases since 2025 challenging private equity buyout prices; nine of 14 filed in 2026 involved them.

Hedge funds have brought or sought to lead at least 11 proposed class actions in Delaware since 2025 challenging prices paid in private equity buyouts. The cases generally allege that directors and executives approved transactions that undervalued the companies.

Nine of the 14 such cases filed in 2026 involved hedge funds, compared with one in 2024. Firms including Carl Icahn’s investment company, Glazer Capital and Empyrean Capital are taking leadership roles or seeking to do so.

The investors are using financial analysis and litigation experience to challenge transaction prices and seek additional compensation for shareholders. The cases have traditionally been brought by individual investors and pension funds.

The increase followed changes to Delaware corporate law after several major companies, including Tesla, reconsidered their incorporation arrangements. The changes eased some deal-approval requirements and made it harder for shareholders to obtain company records.

The litigation is developing alongside renewed interest in appraisal proceedings. In an appraisal case, investors buy shares after a takeover is announced and ask a court to determine the company’s fair value. If the court sets that value above the agreed price, investors may receive the difference and accumulated interest. They can lose money if the court values the company below the offer price.

At least five transactions have faced both shareholder class actions and appraisal challenges since 2025. One is Silver Lake’s $25 billion acquisition of Endeavor Group Holdings. Icahn Enterprises is co-leading a proposed class action related to the deal, while other investors have filed appraisal claims.

Silver Lake has challenged the participation of hedge funds that bought shares after the acquisition was announced. The private equity firm argues that those investors should not be able to seek additional returns through litigation while limiting their exposure to a lower valuation.

In September, Silver Lake sued Icahn’s firm and accused it of colluding with some hedge funds involved in the appraisal proceedings. Icahn’s legal representatives rejected the allegations as baseless and argued that they distracted from claims about the treatment of Endeavor shareholders.

Hedge funds have not secured lead-plaintiff positions in every case. In litigation over 3G Capital’s $9.4 billion acquisition of Skechers, Empyrean Capital, Verition and other investors failed to become lead plaintiffs. The judge appointed Fiduciary Management instead, citing its ownership of Skechers shares before the transaction was announced.

Articles by this author