Free ETF Trading Still Carries Distribution Costs

Zero-commission ETF trades remove a direct charge for investors, but distribution accounted for 48% of UCITS investing costs in 2025, according to ESMA.

Zero-commission ETF trading has reduced the direct cost of buying funds, but it has not removed distribution expenses. Distribution accounted for 48% of total investing costs across the UCITS market, according to an analysis published by the European Securities and Markets Authority in 2025.

Retail ETF purchases are increasingly made through digital brokers and recurring savings plans. Some platforms have commercial arrangements with ETF providers that can include subsidised trading, a share of a fund’s total expense ratio or payments for marketing content.

“There is no single model and commercial arrangements vary considerably depending on the platform and the market in which it operates,” said Hector McNeil, co-founder and co-CEO of HANetf. Arrangements can cover subsidised trading, total expense ratio sharing or targeted content, he added.

Julius Weller, vice president of broker at Scalable Capital, said payments from ETF providers come from the providers’ own resources and are not deducted from client assets. The company has several revenue sources, including interest and lending income, wealth-management and assets-under-management fees, order fees, in-house market making, recurring subscriptions, business-to-business services and its own ETFs.

Scalable Capital aggregates savings-plan orders to reduce clearing, settlement and execution costs to marginal levels, Weller said. That makes zero-commission execution for recurring investments commercially feasible at scale. The company did not provide details of its contractual relationships with partners, citing confidentiality.

Mintos uses a different model. Martins Sulte, the company’s chief executive and co-founder, said Mintos receives no distribution, marketing, total expense ratio-sharing payments or rebates from ETF issuers. Issuers do not subsidise the company’s zero-commission ETF trading, he added.

“We may not earn on ETFs specifically, but the platform as a whole generates the economics that make it possible to offer them at no cost to the investor,” Sulte said. Mintos obtains its ETF catalogue through a partnership with Upvest and has no direct relationship with ETF issuers, he added.

The arrangements mean that a free ETF transaction does not necessarily require an issuer to pay for that specific trade. Platforms can fund the service through subscriptions, lending, interest income or fees from other products. For ETF providers, access to digital platforms remains a commercial consideration.

Digital brokers and savings-plan services can affect which funds retail investors discover and buy. Larger providers have the scale and marketing budgets to form relationships across several platforms and markets. Smaller issuers can use the same channels to reach investors who may not encounter their funds through established brands.

“While larger issuers have the scale and marketing budgets to establish commercial relationships across multiple platforms and markets, these partnerships can also provide opportunities for smaller and newer issuers,” McNeil said. Distribution and marketing arrangements can help new providers reach investors and compete with larger firms, he added.

Kenneth Lamont, a principal at Morningstar, compared promoted products on investment platforms with sponsored listings on consumer websites. He said platforms should clearly disclose commercial arrangements when investors view or purchase funds, subject to the disclosure rules in their jurisdictions.

ESMA’s 2025 findings indicated that execution-only neobrokers were generally less expensive distribution channels for investors than traditional banks and investment firms. With ETF product fees and trading commissions falling, distribution remains part of the cost structure for fund providers.

New funds face a similar challenge to liquidity. Investors often prefer products that already have scale, while funds need assets and trading activity to build scale. Distribution partnerships can give smaller issuers a way to establish visibility, while adding another cost to the ETF industry.

Articles by this author