FINRA Rule 4111 faces scrutiny over limited use
At least a dozen broker-dealers may meet preliminary disclosure thresholds under FINRA Rule 4111, but only two have received restricted status since 2022.
At least a dozen broker-dealers met preliminary disclosure thresholds that can prompt review under Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Rule 4111, yet only two firms have received restricted status since the rule took effect in January 2022.
AdvizorPro identified 20 broker-dealers with at least 10 disclosures per 100 registered representatives from 2021 through 2025. Emerson Equity had the highest rate, with slightly more than 51 disclosures per 100 representatives, followed by Newbridge Securities with more than 43.
Rule 4111 allows FINRA to designate a broker-dealer as a restricted firm when its records indicate a heightened risk to investors. A restricted firm may have to set aside money for investor restitution, undergo more frequent examinations and face proceedings that could lead to expulsion.
FINRA adopted the rule in 2021, and it took effect at the start of 2022. A 2023 revision allowed restricted designations to appear on firms’ BrokerCheck pages. The designation has been used twice.
Reid & Rudiger was expelled from the industry and can no longer operate as a broker-dealer. Spartan Capital Securities was placed on the restricted list in February but later obtained a temporary removal of the designation while challenging FINRA’s findings.
For firms with at least 500 registered representatives, one preliminary threshold is having at least 10% of representatives with an adjudicated event. These events include an adverse arbitration award, a civil or criminal judgment, a regulatory action or a settlement of at least $15,000. Other thresholds include having at least 5% of representatives with pending investment-related claims or at least 10% terminated after an internal investigation.
Firms that meet a threshold can respond before FINRA decides whether to impose restrictions. They can argue that disclosures are duplicated, involve former representatives or do not accurately reflect investor risk. Firms can also avoid the designation by removing representatives with regulatory records or appeal a final decision.
Craig McCann, president of SLCG Economic Consulting, described the rule as giving firms several ways to avoid the designation. The procedures make it possible for firms to “easily and purely superficially avoid” being labeled restricted, he said. “The whole system looks like FINRA is doing something, but it is actually doing nothing,” McCann said.
FINRA declined to comment.
The number of disclosures does not necessarily equal the number of representatives involved or establish that misconduct occurred. Centaurus Financial had slightly more than 33 disclosures per 100 representatives in the AdvizorPro analysis. The firm said most of its disclosures were linked to the collapse of GWG Holdings’ L Bonds, a high-yield debt product that defaulted in 2022.
Paul King, Centaurus’ general counsel, said the disclosures were attached to about 15% of the firm’s representatives. “Any metric that allows disclosures attributable to that small group to reflect adversely on the more than 85% of Centaurus representatives with no disclosures of their own is misleading, logically unsound and fundamentally unfair,” he said.
King said Centaurus and its representatives had no adverse awards or judgments during the period, though the firm and its brokers reached millions of dollars in settlements. In 2023, the Securities and Exchange Commission settled allegations involving two Centaurus brokers and variable interest rate structured products for nearly $350,000.
Michael Bixby, president of the Public Investors Advocate Bar Association, questioned why some firms have much higher disclosure rates than others. LPL Financial, the industry’s largest broker-dealer, had fewer than four disclosures per 100 representatives during the same period, according to AdvizorPro.
BrokerCheck generally records customer complaints even when brokers or firms deny the allegations. Disclosures can also follow representatives from previous employers, making it difficult to determine whether a current firm was responsible for the conduct.
Spartan’s case illustrated the issue. FINRA found that about 10% of its brokers had previously worked at firms expelled by FINRA and that 10.9% faced pending regulatory events. Spartan argued that some disclosures were duplicated or belonged to former representatives. FINRA Deputy Chief Hearing Officer Carla Carloni ordered the case reconsidered, citing inconsistent information and a lack of clarity in the data used to impose a maximum restricted deposit of $1.851 million.








