FCA proposes rules for ESG ratings providers

The UK Financial Conduct Authority has proposed rules to bring ESG ratings providers into its regulatory framework and require clearer disclosure of how their ratings are produced.

The UK Financial Conduct Authority has proposed a framework for environmental, social and governance ratings providers, setting out how the firms would be authorised, supervised and required to explain their ratings to users.

The proposed rules cover ratings that assess an entity, financial instrument or activity against environmental, social or governance factors. They are intended to improve the quality and transparency of ratings used by investors, companies and other financial-market participants.

Providers operating in the UK would come under the FCA’s regulatory framework. They would need to meet requirements covering governance, systems and controls, conflicts of interest, complaints handling and the management of confidential information. The rules would also cover providers based outside the UK when their activities fall within the regime.

Providers would have to disclose information about their rating methods, data sources, assumptions and the limits of their assessments. Users would need enough information to understand what a rating measures and how changes in data or methodology could affect the result.

The framework would not prescribe one method for producing ESG ratings or require providers to use specific environmental, social or governance factors. Providers would remain responsible for their methods. The FCA would supervise whether those methods are applied consistently and described clearly.

The regulator has identified differences between ESG ratings and the way providers describe their products as an issue the framework would address. ESG ratings can be used in investment decisions, corporate reporting and capital allocation, while their methods and purposes vary between providers.

Providers covered by the rules would need FCA authorisation or permission to continue carrying out regulated activities. The FCA would be able to monitor compliance and take enforcement action against firms that fail to meet the requirements.

The proposals follow work by the UK government and the FCA to bring ESG ratings into the UK’s financial-services regulatory system.

Articles by this author