Effective N reveals hidden fund concentration
A TMX VettaFi webcast examined effective N, a measure of portfolio concentration. On Nov. 16, SPY had an effective N of 48.3, compared with 114.47 for PRF.
Effective N is calculated as the inverse of the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, a measure of portfolio concentration. It converts a fund’s holdings into the equivalent number of equally weighted stocks. A fund with an effective N of 10 has the same concentration as a portfolio of 10 equally weighted stocks, regardless of its actual number of holdings.
Brent Leadbetter, head of RAFI Distribution at TMX VettaFi, discussed the measure during the webcast. He explained that investors who use index funds for diversification may face greater concentration when a benchmark becomes heavily weighted toward a small group of large companies.
SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) held 504 stocks on Nov. 16 but had an effective N of 48.3. Its holdings therefore had the same concentration as a portfolio of fewer than 50 equally weighted stocks. Invesco RAFI US 1000 ETF (PRF) held 989 stocks and had an effective N of 114.47.
SPY’s 10 largest holdings accounted for 36.98% of its assets. Apple was the largest holding, at 7.98%. PRF’s top 10 holdings represented 23.28% of assets, while Apple accounted for 4.86%.
SPY uses market-cap weighting, which gives larger allocations to companies with higher market values. PRF uses fundamental weighting, which bases allocations on measures of a company’s economic size rather than its share price. This results in smaller allocations to the largest companies than those found in a traditional market-cap-weighted index.
“ One of the reasons many of us started investing in indices in the first place was to get diversification,” Leadbetter said during the webcast. “You’re not getting the same level of diversification today in the S&P that you’ve gotten historically, because of how concentrated it has become at the top of the market.”
Effective N does not measure the number of securities in a fund. It indicates how evenly assets are distributed and how many holdings have a meaningful effect on performance. A lower figure indicates greater concentration in individual stocks or groups of companies, while a higher figure indicates a more even distribution of assets.
VettaFi is the index provider for PRF and receives an index licensing fee. PRF is not issued, sponsored, endorsed or sold by VettaFi. VettaFi is not responsible for the fund’s issuance, administration, marketing or trading.








