AI Shopping Agents Could Shift, Not Increase, Spending
AI shopping agents may shift grocery and retail spending among companies without increasing total purchases, according to a State Street Investment Management report published Thursday.
AI shopping agents may change which retailers receive consumer spending without increasing total purchases, according to a State Street Investment Management report published Thursday. The tools can compare prices, track household supplies, suggest replacements and complete orders for shoppers.
The report examined “agentic commerce,” which uses artificial intelligence to manage parts of the shopping process. Its authors, Mariola Pokorska, David Huang and Jeff Looby, cited Meta Platforms’ Muse as one example. They wrote that shoppers may shift purchases to retailers with lower prices, faster delivery or simpler service.
The report linked the technology to possible changes in market share, pricing power and profit margins in consumer staples and consumer discretionary companies.
Walmart has reported higher average order values among users of its Sparky AI assistant. Walmart represents 11.37% of the State Street Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR ETF, known by its ticker XLP. The report described the early results as “encouraging but not conclusive,” noting that shoppers making larger or more research-intensive purchases may have been more likely to use the assistant.
Regular buying patterns could limit changes in overall demand for consumer staples, according to the report. Automated restocking and easy product substitutions could pressure weaker brands, while established brands with broad distribution could gain sales.
The report identified expensive, infrequent purchases as an area where AI could have a larger effect. Large retailers, travel platforms, home-improvement companies and businesses with established delivery networks could benefit from AI-assisted shopping. Companies that rely heavily on paid search advertising or sell products that are easy to replace could face greater exposure.
AI tools could reduce restaurant operating costs. McDonald’s has reported more than 90% accuracy for its AI drive-thru ordering system and expects the technology to save at least 50 labor hours a week as it expands. McDonald’s represents 4.69% of the State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF, or XLY, and gained 12.2% over the past month, according to State Street.
The report expects retailers to direct much of their AI savings to lower prices and improved customer service rather than lasting margin gains. Warehouse automation could give larger retailers an advantage because of the cost of installing the systems. About 25% of warehouses worldwide use some form of automation, while about 10% use advanced technology, according to the report.
Consumer stocks have gained as technology stocks declined. XLP rose 3.04% over the past month, ranking second among 11 sector funds. XLY increased 1.2%. State Street’s S&P 500 fund fell 6.6%, while its information-technology fund declined 13.6% over the same period.








