AI May Raise Advice Standards Without Lifting RIA Margins

AI may help registered investment advisers serve more clients, but competition could limit lasting margin gains, experts said at an industry conference.

Artificial intelligence could improve the quality of financial advice without producing lasting margin gains for registered investment advisers, according to a debate at the ADVISE AI conference. Michael Kitces of Kitces.com and Joel Bruckenstein, president of T3, disagreed over whether AI will expand adviser capacity. They agreed that competition could reduce any financial benefit over time.

Kitces argued that AI may increase the amount of work advisers perform rather than reduce it. Bruckenstein took a more optimistic view, saying firms could serve more clients after completing the initial work of adopting and refining the technology.

The debate focused on how firms use the time AI saves. Kitces cited the Jevons paradox, which describes how greater efficiency can increase demand for a resource. He compared that effect with financial planning, where tools that produce more recommendations can create additional work for advisers and clients.

For example, planning software that once generated seven recommendations may now produce 12, including five an adviser had not previously considered. Each recommendation requires an explanation, potentially turning one client meeting into two. A client who uses ChatGPT may return with additional questions, creating more follow-up work.

Kitces estimated that the software could save about an hour during plan preparation while creating three to seven hours of additional work. “It’s better for the clients,” he said.

Bruckenstein viewed much of that extra work as part of the adoption period. “Initially, because you may have more ideas, there’s going to be a transition period where you put some of that into place,” he said. “But once it’s in place … you can have new capacity to take on more clients as well.”

Kitces pointed to the financial advice industry’s experience with technology over roughly 30 years, including the internet, smartphones, robo-advisers and AI. He said the median overhead expense ratio has remained near 40%, while the standard advisory fee has stayed close to 1%.

Technology has enabled advisers to provide more detailed planning, Kitces noted, but he said it has not reduced expenses or pushed fees lower. Bruckenstein countered that clients receive more services for roughly the same fee.

Kitces described two firms that use AI and eliminate an administrative position. One firm could keep the savings and improve its margin. The other could invest the savings in a new client service. The second firm could gain an advantage in client retention and competition, he said.

Bruckenstein identified another potential source of savings: reducing the need for specialist roles. If a tool can produce a portfolio at the level expected from a chartered financial analyst in seven minutes or less, a firm with three such analysts might eventually need only one. The firm could retain the savings or invest them in services.

Private-equity-backed and debt-funded firms are likely to apply strong pressure for AI adoption and efficiency gains, Bruckenstein said. Kitces acknowledged that some firms may see short-term improvements but expects competition to reduce margin gains over time.

Kitces did not advise firms to avoid AI. Advisers will need to keep pace with competitors that adopt the technology, even if productivity gains are used for additional client services instead of higher profits.

Articles by this author