Advisor Recruiters Face Little Formal Oversight, Consultant Says

Philip Waxelbaum of Masada Consulting urges advisors to check recruiters’ records, experience, references and compensation before changing firms.

Financial advisor recruiters face no mandatory industry credential, supervised experience requirement or minimum record of responsibility in financial services, according to Philip Waxelbaum, founder of Masada Consulting.

Waxelbaum estimates that up to 33% of advisors recruited to new firms do not reach their seventh anniversary there. He attributes many of those outcomes to poor selection and says a firm change can affect a practice, its clients and its employees for years.

Financial advisors are examined, registered, trained and supervised. Recruiters can enter the field without comparable requirements. Waxelbaum says experience as a realtor, marketer, accountant, athlete, product wholesaler or support employee does not establish the ability to assess an advisory firm, negotiate transition terms or identify risks in a practice.

Some recruiters have expanded their work beyond recommending a destination firm, according to Waxelbaum. Their services may include advice on client segmentation, staffing, pricing, succession, investment construction, mergers and acquisitions, and enterprise value. He questions whether recruiters offering that advice have managed advisory practices or financial services businesses.

Waxelbaum also warns that artificial intelligence can produce polished business plans that make limited experience appear greater. He maintains that software cannot replace judgment developed through managing advisors and handling failed or difficult transitions.

Personal appeal should not be treated as proof of competence, Waxelbaum says. A recruiter’s ability to hold sensitive discussions does not establish whether a transition offer has sound economics, whether assets can be transferred or whether a proposed firm fits a particular practice.

He recommends reviewing a recruiter’s professional history, licenses, regulatory records, litigation and disciplinary history. Advisors should ask where the recruiter worked, how long the person stayed in each position, what authority they held, whether they managed a profit-and-loss statement and whether they supervised advisors or handled unsuccessful transitions.

Advisors should ask recruiters to analyze the specific practice under consideration. Areas for review include client demographics, team agreements, deferred compensation, nonportable assets, lending, alternative investments, pricing, insurance, real estate and succession plans. Waxelbaum says a recruiter should be able to explain why a proposed firm may be a poor fit.

References should include advisors who changed firms recently and those who made a transition two or three years ago. They can provide information about how much business transferred, whether staff stayed, whether the technology worked and whether the promised financial terms held up after expenses.

Advisors should also determine who pays the recruiter and whether compensation changes based on the destination firm, transaction terms or decision speed. Waxelbaum identifies a recruiter’s willingness to recommend staying with the current firm as a test of independence.

He urges advisors to ask whether a recruiter can recommend that they remain where they are. Advisors retain responsibility for the effects of a firm change because they control the business and client relationships involved.

Articles by this author